Delhi High Court Criticizes Wikipedia in Contempt Case, Threatens Block in India
In a strong rebuke, the Delhi High Court has issued stern remarks against Wikipedia, indicating that it may ask the Indian government to block the platform in the country. The court's comments came during a contempt case involving ANI (Asian News International), where Wikipedia has been accused of not complying with the court’s previous orders.
Background of the Case
ANI filed a defamation lawsuit against Wikipedia after the news agency's page on the platform was edited to include objectionable and misleading information. The edited content suggested that ANI was being used as a propaganda tool for the current government, prompting ANI to seek legal action. The court had previously directed Wikipedia to provide details of the three individuals responsible for editing the page, but Wikipedia has yet to comply with the order, leading ANI to return to court, accusing Wikipedia of contempt.
What Happened in Court Today?
During today's hearing, the court questioned why Wikipedia had not adhered to its earlier order. Wikipedia’s counsel responded by explaining that the platform needed time to present certain matters before the court, as Wikipedia is not based in India.
However, the court expressed dissatisfaction with the explanation, stating, "This is not about whether Wikipedia is based in India or not; the issue is the non-compliance with the court's order." The court further warned that it could initiate contempt proceedings against Wikipedia and take steps to block the platform in India if necessary.
"We will not hesitate to shut down your commercial transactions here," the court warned, adding that it may ask the government to block access to Wikipedia in India. The court reiterated that similar arguments had been made by Wikipedia previously and concluded by stating, "If you do not like India, please do not operate here."
The court's harsh remarks have escalated the case, raising questions about Wikipedia's operations in India and its adherence to local laws and regulations.
